[2022] NewSim Feedback

[Ezaco]

Interface is recording a loss, though I did win: https://www.simfba.com/index.php?threads/week-5-saturday-night.3653

 

[Jieret]

During the week 5 (noon) Ball State-WMU game, WMU punted from the Ball State 33 for a touchback. The punt was recorded as traveling 67 yards, as though WMU was punting from their own 33.

[Ezaco]

Not sure how much it matters, but I did just notice also my game against Vanderbilt in the Interface is showing its location at Vanderbilt, but the game was played at Kentucky.

[Pumph]

I'm sure it's been mentioned before, but we need to get punting stats fixed.

 

 

28

17

3

1:49

SDSU

4

7

42 UNLV

Punt

P Aron Upshaw punts for 55 yards. Touchback.

 

This gets recorded as a 55-yard punt. In real life, this would be a 42-yard punt and 22-yard net.

[Pumph]

Also, with my team ahead 45-27, UNLV scored a TD on the game's final play. They then kicked the extra point to make the final score 45-34.

 

Unless the PAT could affect the outcome, if the time expires on the final play, the PAT is not attempted. Not a big deal, but if it is an easy fix, let's get it right. Thanks.

[PoopyRhinoPickle]

 

CB Christian Minaya is a Bowling Green player, not sure how he blocked a Bowling Green FG attempt.

[Piercewise1]

Jacksonville fails to gain enough yards on 2nd down and the Browns immediately get the ball back. Checked the stat sheet and Stephen Tabbert has a fumble that doesn't appear anywhere on play by play; Browns don't have a forced fumble but do have a recovered fumble (Luis Chavez). So I guess the sim registered a fumble but didn't record it in the log?

 

[Pumph]

23	0	2	7:6	SDSU	3	2	49 SDSU	Run	RB Derek Crockett carries for -4 yards. Ran out of bounds. PENALTY: Neutral Zone Infraction ILB Kila Ahmed
23	0	2	6:49	SDSU	1	5	46 BYU	Pass	QB Hung-Chih Anderson complete to RB Derek Crockett for 5 yards. Tackled by CB Rico Harrison.

 

3rd and 2 - 5 yard penalty gave us a 1st down.

But, it made it 1st and 5, not 1st and 10 as it should have been.

[Pumph]

We had a DE return an interception for a TD. That TD is not noted in the box score in any way. (Yes we got the points for it) Just thinking things like defensive scores should be a stat that should be recorded in the box score.

[tsweezy]

38 DET	Pass	QB Randall Hansen is sacked by OLB Karl Rosania for -16 yards. . PENALTY: Offensive Holding OG Carmelo Goto
17	7	3	11:41	DET	3	7	38 DET	Pass	QB Randall Hansen scrambles for 4 yards. Tackled by DE James Wood

Had a sack and offensive holding and neither one counted while they re-did the down

[Bundy]

Play

Current Score: MIST 6 - WISC 0

Quarter: 1 | Time Remaining: 6:8

Possession: WISC

2nd and 3

Line of Scrimmage: 37 WISC

Type of Play

Pass

Result

QB Lance Enright complete to WR Colton Porter for 10 yards. Tackled by CB Maikel Moreland. PENALTY: Offensive Holding OT Matt Fulton

 

[12:30 PM]

Play

Current Score: MIST 6 - WISC 0

Quarter: 1 | Time Remaining: 5:47

Possession: WISC

2nd and 3

Line of Scrimmage: 37 WISC

Type of Play

Pass

Result

QB Lance Enright incomplete. Intended for WR Colton Porter.

 

 

 

 

was watching the Michigan State - Wisconsin game in discord and noticed holding did not change the yard line or distance to go

[Bundy]

Play

Current Score: MICH 0 - MIST 14

Quarter: 1 | Time Remaining: 1:56

Possession: MICH

1st and 10

Line of Scrimmage: 30 MICH

Type of Play

Pass

Result

QB Bobo Sims complete to FB Phil Hicks for 8 yards. Tackled by SS Taylor Armbrister. PENALTY: Offensive Holding OT Alex Garcia

 

[5:10 PM]

Play

Current Score: MICH 0 - MIST 14

Quarter: 1 | Time Remaining: 1:35

Possession: MICH

1st and 10

Line of Scrimmage: 30 MICH

Type of Play

Pass

Result

QB Bobo Sims complete to WR Kamalei Dawson for 5 yards. Tackled by OLB Tray Johnson. PENALTY: Illegal Block OT Alex Garcia

 

 

Holding on Michigan didnt change their yard line or yards to go, was just a replay down

[Bundy]

Quarter: 1 | Time Remaining: 1:17

Possession: MICH

1st and 20

Line of Scrimmage: 20 MICH

Type of Play

Pass

Result

QB Bobo Sims incomplete. Intended for WR Kamalei Dawson.

 

 

 

the illegal block on that second play DID get recorded properly, but it should have led to like 1st + 30

[Piercewise1]

https://www.simfba.com/index.php?threads/week-11-thursday.3857/

 

ULM scores a TD in the final minute. Down 18-16, they kick an extra point and lose by 1 point. Arkansas State had a safety earlier in the game that was not captured in the box score, not sure if that matters.

 

[acewulf]

UCF QB Jonathan LaVine threw 2 INTs in today's game. 1 to my ILB Jurrell Brown and 1 to my CB Jevoni Walker. Only Jevoni is listed as having an INT and LaVine is listed as having 1 INT.

 

https://www.simfba.com/index.php?threads/week-11-friday.3852/

[Rocketcan]

Can you give the quarter and time on the clock for both INTs?

[acewulf]

Jurrell Brown - Q2, 13:49

Jevoni Walker - Q2, 0:49

[Rocketcan]

Looks like a bug with the penalty on offense. It was declined but not recorded as an INT for stat purposes.

[Bundy]

TCU managed to score so it ddnt hold them back, but instead of being 1st + Goal it was listed as 1st + 97 and then 2nd + 94.

[Bundy]

offensive holding didnt change down or distance, just replayed down

[Bundy]

Offensive holding on what would have turned to 4th + 2, but we accepted the penalty for some reason and it DID change the distance.

[npklemm]

cowardly punt

[Sarge]

Week 12 CFB Afternoon game UGA FL Neutral Site

 

UGA got the ball to start the game. FL scored going into the half. I think the sim fucked up because it had UGA kick off at the start of 2nd half then realized possession needed to change because the 2nd half started and made UF immediately kick, causing UGA to start with the ball in the 2nd half as well giving us an extra possession.

 

@Weeze

 

01420:5FLA11021 UGAPassQB Morgan Neal complete to WR Michael Burawa for 21 yards. TOUCHDOWN!

61420:-14FLAN/AN/A3 UGAExtra PointK Derrick Gasol's extra point attempt is no good.

614315:00UGAN/AN/A35 UGAKickoffK Chad Zeller kicks for 68 yards. Fielded 3 yards. deep in the endzone by RB Sam Haynes Touchback.

614315:00FLAN/AN/A35 FLAKickoffK Derrick Gasol kicks for 65 yards. Fielded at the goalline by RB Roy MejiaRB Roy Mejia returns the ball 30 yards. Ran out of bounds.

[smackemz]

Just want to add this as something to review in the offseason.

 

Week 5 - Noon games. Kansas at WVU. Kansas leads 21-17, but WVU forces a punt with 2:49 remaining. WVU runs the ball a few times and then passes down the field, where they just let time expire at the Kansas 4.... There should be some kind of hurry up logic or something, feels like 2:49 is ample time to drive down without letting the clock expire.

 

17	21	4	2:49	KANS	4	4	43 KANS	Punt	P Victor Weigel punts for 59 yards. Touchback.
17	21	4	2:35	WVU	1	10	20 WVU	Run	RB Chad Dolis carries for 5 yards. Tackled by DE Zack Luke.
17	21	4	2:8	WVU	2	5	25 WVU	Run	FB Patrick Nuno carries for 2 yards. Tackled by CB James Davidson.
17	21	4	1:46	WVU	3	3	27 WVU	Run	RB Mario Allen carries for -1 yard. Tackled by DT Mike Brantly.
17	21	4	1:18	WVU	4	4	26 WVU	Pass	QB Shelby Musa complete to WR Avery Sterling for 20 yards. Tackled by SS Chance Johnson.
17	21	4	0:59	WVU	1	10	46 WVU	Pass	QB Shelby Musa complete to WR Kevin Purcell for 22 yards. Tackled by FS Kevin Suarez.
17	21	4	0:37	WVU	1	10	32 KANS	Pass	QB Shelby Musa complete to WR Avery Sterling for 23 yards. Tackled by CB Tim Keller.
17	21	4	0:18	WVU	1	9	9 KANS	Pass	QB Shelby Musa complete to TE Anfernee Ford for 5 yards. Tackled by ILB Ezekiel Sands.

Edited October 2, 2022 by smackemz

[Piercewise1]

 

Safety is somehow counted as a TD for the other team.