[2021] NewSim Feedback

[Nittany Boiler]

1 3:18 MIZZ 1 10 33 MIZZ Pass QB Aaron Leamon incomplete. Intended for RB Vyncint Brooks. 1 3:9 MIZZ 2 10 33 MIZZ Run RB Vyncint Brooks carries for -2 yards. Ran out of bounds. 1 2:49 TAMU 1 10 31 MIZZ Run RB Brandon Bullock carries for 1 yard. Tackled by DT Caleb Suarez. 1 2:11 TAMU 2 9 30 MIZZ Pass QB Victor Murphy complete to TE Alex Nowitzki for 16 yards. Tackled by ILB Ryan Wilson. 1 1:51 TAMU 1 10 14 MIZZ Run RB Brandon Bullock carries for 2 yards. Ran out of bounds. 1 1:32 TAMU 2 8 12 MIZZ Pass QB Victor Murphy incomplete. Intended for TE Alex Nowitzki. 1 1:24 TAMU 3 8 12 MIZZ Run RB Brandon Bullock carries for 12 yards. TOUCHDOWN!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Run out of bounds (should be 3 and 12 ay MIZZ 31 for MIZZ) but possession change from MIZZ to TAMU with excellent field position and a resulting TD?

Edited August 15, 2021 by Nittany Boiler

[Nittany Boiler]

MIZZ

Chris Bradley

TE

7

3

38

12.67

0

0

 

Third string TE Chris Bradley instead of TE Jason Fleer. Not sure why - no change to depth chart or scheme.

[BabaYaga]

Week 8: Friday. Eastern Michigan was given a free PAT.

 

4	13:7	WMU	4	7	5 WMU	Punt	P Chandler Cuevas punts for -5 yards. BLOCKED by CB Svi Liriano.
4	12:54	EMU	1	N/A	0 WMU	Pass	QB Ryan Swanson incomplete. Intended for FB Laurence Feiler.
4	12:33	EMU	N/A	N/A	3 WMU	Extra Point	K Marcell Lauina's extra point attempt is good.

[Rocketcan]

Please give me your WR, RB, and TE depth chart as it stood for this game.

[Bundy]

Boujee Bundy — Today at 9:39 PM

can Bishop Sycamore get added for realism

[Nittany Boiler]

Issues: MIZZ vs. VANDY

 

Incorrect Penalty

1	5:20	VAND	3	7	29 VAND	Pass	QB Gehrig Crecelius incomplete. Intended for WR Drew Bryan. PENALTY: Neutral Zone Infraction OLB J.P. Bracy
1	5:13	VAND	3	10	34 VAND	Run	RB Justin Cooks carries for 2 yards. Tackled by DT Brian Ford.

 

Incorrect Interception / Change of Possession

1	4:12	MIZZ	1	10	49 VAND	Pass	QB Aaron Leamon intercepted by FS Josh Westerman returned for 0 yards from the LOS. intended for FB Lucas Walford.
1	4:2	MIZZ	2	10	49 VAND	Pass	QB Aaron Leamon complete to WR Owa Guzman for 6 yards. Tackled by SS Mason Hauschild.

 

Incorrect Penalty

2	14:50	VAND	1	10	47 MIZZ	Pass	QB Gehrig Crecelius incomplete. Intended for WR Drew Bryan. PENALTY: Offensive Holding C T.J. Fernandez
2	14:30	VAND	1	10	47 MIZZ	Pass	QB Gehrig Crecelius complete to WR Ifeadi Adams for 19 yards. Tackled by OLB J.P. Bracy.

 

Yardage on Interception?

2	7:47	VAND	3	8	23 VAND	Pass	QB Gehrig Crecelius intercepted by FS Aristides Jackson returned for 67 yards from the LOS. intended for WR Drew Bryan.
2	7:27	MIZZ	1	10	10 MIZZ	Pass	QB Aaron Leamon incomplete. Thrown Away.

 

Incorrect Penalty

3	5:33	MIZZ	2	9	33 MIZZ	Run	RB Vyncint Brooks carries for 1 yard. Tackled by DE Geoff Lakins. PENALTY: False Start OG Luke Gillislee
3	5:20	MIZZ	2	10	28 MIZZ	Pass	QB Aaron Leamon incomplete. Thrown Away.

 

Incorrect Change of Possession

4	2:28	MIZZ	1	10	25 MIZZ	Run	RB Vyncint Brooks carries for -2 yards. Ran out of bounds.
4	2:7	VAND	1	10	23 MIZZ	Pass	QB Gehrig Crecelius incomplete. Intended for RB Justin Cooks.

 

*** Changed the game - Vanderbilt scored immediately and pulled within 6 points

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Seven Interceptions in one game after 2 interceptions in the first 9 games???????

[rcarlson77]

Should have been a safety?

 

2	4:49	WVU	1	10	16 WVU	Pass	QB Logan Gabriel is sacked by DE Arden Ware for -7 yards. .
2	4:37	WVU	2	17	9 WVU	Pass	QB Logan Gabriel is sacked by DE Arden Ware and DT Liam Finney for -15 yards. .
2	4:26	WVU	3	32	-6 WVU	Pass	QB Logan Gabriel incomplete. Intended for FB Patrick Nuno.
2	4:14	WVU	4	32	-6 WVU	Punt	P Brent Martin punts for 46 yards. RB Fernando Gonzalez returns the ball 14 yards. Tackled by RB Austin Brady.
2	4:2	TTU	1	10	26 WVU	Pass	QB Jordan Madero complete to WR Nick Wake for 19 yards. Tackled by FS DaQuan Watson.
2	3:41	TTU	1	7	7 WVU	Run	RB Fernando Gonzalez carries for 7 yards. TOUCHDOWN!

[kgreene829]

The balls on this kicker to try and make a field goal from around the world.

1

4:23

NEV

4

7

37 USAF

Field Goal

K Dorren Peraza's -11 yard field goal attempt is no good.

 

This happened a couple of times just looks like it is forgetting to add a 0 for the time

4

7:12

NEV

4

8

26 NEV

Punt

P Travis Gonzalez punts for 36 yards. CB Nick Houser returns the ball 12 yards. Ran out of bounds.

4

7:0

USAF

1

10

50

Run

QB Anthony Sweeney carries for 1 yard. Tackled by DE Andre Brown.

4

6:18

USAF

2

9

49 NEV

Pass

QB Anthony Sweeney complete to RB Malcolm Jernigan for 4 yards. Tackled by CB DaeSean Thompson.

 

4

3:47

NEV

3

10

20 NEV

Run

QB Nelson Holland carries for -2 yards. Tackled by DE Julian Thomas.

4

3:9

NEV

4

12

18 NEV

Punt

P Travis Gonzalez punts for 72 yards. WR Eric Steele returns the ball 14 yards. Ran out of bounds.

4

2:57

USAF

1

10

24 USAF

Run

RB Malcolm Jernigan carries for 8 yards. Ran out of bounds.

[Jmjacobs]

3

7:29

UCLA

1

-5

-5 CAL

Run

QB Hiram Maronde carries for -5 yards. TOUCHDOWN!

[TuscanSota]

@Rocketcan

[Rocketcan]

Can you post the last play before it was on a negative yard line and then any plays between that play and this one that you posted?

 

I hope that makes sense.

[Jmjacobs]

3	8:44	UCLA	1	10	35 UCLA	Run	RB Dan Garcia carries for 1 yard. Tackled by DT Stephen McCalister.
3	8:7	UCLA	2	9	36 UCLA	Pass	QB Hiram Maronde complete to WR Jose Colabello for 38 yards. Tackled by ILB Morgan King.
3	7:48	UCLA	1	10	26 CAL	Pass	QB Hiram Maronde complete to RB Dan Garcia for 16 yards. Tackled by CB Adam Ijalana. PENALTY: Defensive Pass Interference CB Breyvic Asiata
3	7:29	UCLA	1	-5	-5 CAL	Run	QB Hiram Maronde carries for -5 yards. TOUCHDOWN!
3	7:12	UCLA	N/A	N/A	3 CAL	Extra Point	K Andrew Trinnaman's extra point attempt is good.

[Jmjacobs]

seems like a 15 yard penalty for PI when on the 10 put it at the -5 yard line

[Rocketcan]

Thank you. This is very helpful!

[ChizDippler]

 

Here is a whole mess of bugs. yardage on the punt was way off. then penalty on TD....

[subsequent]

 

Wisconsin had a Touchdown that also had a false start. Touchdown was not included in the QB's box score, but did count into the overall score, which should not have counted as it was an offensive penalty.

 

https://www.simfba.com/index.php?threads/bowl-week-2-saturday-noon.2913/#post-10261

[subsequent]

Wishlist for stats:

 

Individual sacks allowed

Pancakes

D/ST TDs

Turnover yards (Int and Fumble Recovery yards)

Safeties

Punt yards (not present in the current stats sheets, but does appear in box score)

Passes defended

 

@tsweezy any more?

Edited November 16, 2021 by subsequent

[Sarge]

Drive data would be awesome. Just something in the stat sheet called "Drives" it were possible. It would help me flesh out some defensive metrics for teams.

[subsequent]

Ongoing stats feedback:

• Linebacker (unsure for DL) total tackles may be low
  
  • Our top 20 - 68-87 tackles
    
  • 2019 IRL top ~20 - 114-149 tackles (one outlier at 181)
    
  • 2018 IRL top ~20 - 126-155 tackles (one outlier at 176)
    
  • 2017 IRL top ~20 - 117-153 tackles (one outlier at 173)
    

  [*]DE/DT tackles MAY be too high

  • I don't have great numbers to go through, but the NCAA stats website only shows around the top 500 players for tackles
    
    • Overall
      
      • Top 24 players (due to ties)
        
        • Solo tackles
          
          • Average of 57.67
            
          • High of 64 (two players)
            
          • Low of 55 (five players)
            

          [*]Assisted tackles

          • Average of 7.6
            
          • High of 11 (one player)
            
          • Low of 7 (13 players)
            

          [*]Total tackles

          • Average of 61.2
            
          • High of 66 (one player)
            
          • Low of 59 (five players)
            

      [*]2019

      • 15 players listed as DL in the top 500 players by # of tackles list
        
        • Solo tackles
          
          • Average of 34.13
            
          • High of 54 (one player)
            
          • Low of 18 (two players)
            

          [*]Assisted tackles

          • Average of 33.67
            
          • High of 46 (one player)
            
          • Low of 16 (one player)
            

          [*]Total tackles

          • Average of 67.8
            
          • High of 99 (one player)
            
          • Low of 54 (one player)
            

      [*]2018

      • 28 players listed as DL in the top 500 players by # of tackles list
        
        • Solo tackles
          
          • Average of 33.82
            
          • High of 74 (massive outlier as next is 47) (one player)
            
          • Low of 16 (one player)
            

          [*]Assisted tackles

          • Average of 33.04
            
          • High of 47 (one player)
            
          • Low of 18 (one player)
            

          [*]Total tackles

          • Average of 66.86
            
          • High of 118 (outlier as most are below 70) (one player)
            
          • Low of 56 (one player)
            

      [*]2017

      • 26 players listed as DL in the top 500 players by # of tackles list
        
        • Solo tackles
          
          • Average of 34.15
            
          • High of 47 (two players)
            
          • Low of 10 (massive outlier as next is 24) (one player)
            

          [*]Assisted tackles

          • Average of 36.69
            
          • High of 66 (one player)
            
          • Low of 20 (one player)
            

          [*]Total tackles

          • Average of 70.85
            
          • High of 103 (one player)
            
          • Low of 55 (one player)
            

  [*]Deeper dive into tackles

  • Overall
    
    • For top 20 players by solo tackles
      
      • Average of 73.9
        
        • High of 87 (one player)
          
        • Low of 69 (one player)
          

      [*]For top 21 players by assisted tackles (due to ties)

      • Average of 8.76
        
        • High of 13 (one player)
          
        • Low of 8 (12 players)
          

      [*]For top 20 players by total tackles

      • Average of 77.7
        
        • High of 88 (one player)
          
        • Low of 73 (one player)
          

      [*]Note: the player with the most solo tackles only had one assisted tackle, so player with most solo tackles and most total tackles is same player

    [*]2019 IRL

    • Top 24 players by solo tackles (due to ties)
      
      • Average of 71.42
        
        • High of 103 (one player)
          
        • Low of 66 (five players)
          

      [*]Top 20 players by assisted tackles

      • Average of 67.71
        
        • High of 86 (one player)
          
        • Low of 59 five players)
          

      [*]Top 20 players by total tackles

      • Average of 126.48
        
        • High of 181 (one player)
          
        • Low of 114 five players)
          

    [*]2018 IRL

    • Top 20 players by solo tackles
      
      • Average of 78.91
        
        • High of 108 (one player)
          
        • Low of 71 (four players)
          

      [*]Top 20 players by assisted tackles

      • Average of 73.75
        
        • High of 90 (one player)
          
        • Low of 62 (two players)
          

      [*]Top 20 players by total tackles

      • Average of 140.05
        
        • High of 176 (one player)
          
        • Low of 127 (two players)
          

    [*]2017 IRL

    • Top 21 players by solo tackles (due to ties)
      
      • Average of 78.48
        
        • High of 94 (one player)
          
        • Low of 69 (two players)
          

      [*]Top 21 players by assisted tackles (due to ties)

      • Average of 74.48
        
        • High of 96 (one player)
          
        • Low of 62 (two players)
          

      [*]Top 20 players by total tackles

      • Average of 135.55
        
        • High of 173 (one player)
          
        • Low of 120 (one player)
          

  [*]Field goal kicking needs a buff

  • Overall, FG% was 2103/3302 (~64%)
    
  • 2019 IRL - 75%
    
  • 2018 IRL - 74%
    
  • 2017 IRL - 73%
    

  [*]XP kicking needs a buff

  • Overall, XP% was 3041/3267 (~93%)
    
  • 2019 IRL - 97%
    
  • 2018 IRL - 97%
    
  • 2017 IRL - 97%
    

  [*]Sacks allowed may be too low

  • 6 teams with 5 sacks allowed, 9 teams with 4 sacks allowed, 5 teams with 3 sacks allowed, 6 teams with 2 sacks allowed, 3 teams with 1 sack allowed, 1 team with 0 sacks allowed
    
  • 2019 IRL - 1 team with 4 sacks allowed, 1 team with 8 sacks allowed, 128 teams with 12 or more sacks allowed
    
  • 2018 IRL - 1 team with 3 sacks allowed, 1 team with 7 sacks allowed, 1 team with 8 sacks allowed, 126 teams with 10 or more sacks allowed
    
  • 2017 IRL - 1 team with 1 sack allowed, 1 team with 8 sacks allowed, 127 teams with 10 or more sacks allowed
    

  [*]Individual sacks looks low as well

  • Overall, for top 28 players by sacks (due to ties)
    
    • Average of 6.82
      
      • High of 9 (one player)
        
      • Low of 6 (14 players)
        

    [*]2019 IRL

    • Average of 12 (out of 22 due to ties)
      
      • High of 16.5 (one player)
        
      • Low of 9.5 (three players)
        

    [*]2018 IRL

    • Average of 11 (out of 25 due to ties)
      
      • High of 17.5 (one player)
        
      • Low of 9.5 (seven players)
        

    [*]2017 IRL

    • Average of 9.8 (out of 32 due to ties)
      
      • High of 14 (one player)
        
      • Low of 8.5 (13 players)
        

  [*]Overall, offenses (specifically PaYDs, PaYD/attempt) needs to be nerfed or passing defense needs to be buffed

  • Overall, for top 20 QB:
    
    • PaYDs: 4463.8
      
    • Comp: 325.55
      
    • Attempts: 506.85
      
    • PaYD/Attempt (min. 100 attempts): 9.91
      
    • Comp% (min. 100 attempts): 69.82%
      
    • TD: 32.15
      
    • INT: 17.15
      

    [*]2019 IRL:

    • PaYDs 3904
      
    • Comp: 305.25
      
    • Attempts: 472.05
      
    • PaYD/Attempt (min. 100 attempts): 9.26
      
    • Comp%: 68.5%
      
    • TD: 33.65 (out of 23 players due to ties)
      
    • INT: 12.42 (out of 24 players due to ties)
      

    [*]2018 IRL:

    • PaYDs: 3827.75
      
    • Comp: 301.7
      
    • Attempts: 466.35
      
    • PaYD/Attempt (min. 100 attempts): 9.11
      
    • Comp%: 67.76%
      
    • TD: 32.71 (out of 21 players due to ties)
      
    • INT: 12.82 (out of 22 players due to ties)
      

    [*]2017 IRL:

    • PaYDs: 3947.25
      
    • Comp: 303.05
      
    • Attempts: 482.2
      
    • PaYD/Attempt (min. 100 attempts): 8.98
      
    • Comp%: 66.03%
      
    • TD: 32.7
      
    • INT: 13.29 (out of 24 players due to ties)
      

Edited November 27, 2021 by subsequent

[Rocketcan]

Can you list out exactly what data you want for each drive?

[Jieret]

Week 9 Noon: Lousiville-Wake Forest ended on a defensive penalty. WF should have received an untimed down.

[Minnow]

I had a weird occurrence happen in my week 10 game Buffalo vs Miami

I scored touchdown by running a Run play with one second left in the half. The sim went into negative time for the extra point and went Into the 3rd quarter. Their team kicked off as I was set to receive the kick. My drive never happened as it forced another kickoff after the halftime kickoff.

 

Second image shows a change of possession occurring when that never happened

Edited September 11, 2022 by Minnow

[Minnow]

One could also ask what coach in their right mind would run the ball when ten yards from the end zone with time set to expire when I'm down by 3 points and I'm set to receive the 2nd half. Just kick the field goal.